Integration at Work, AV
Install Guides

Why does my house have fifteen light switches on one wall?

TETroy Erickson — owner, Integration at Work, AV

Your house has fifteen switches on one wall because the open floor plan won and the wiring convention never caught up. Every fixture, every zone and every outdoor circuit needs somewhere to be controlled from, and when the kitchen, dining and great room became one room, all of those switches landed in one place by the door.

Nobody designed that wall. It accumulated.

Why did this happen to newer houses and not older ones?

Older homes are simpler because they had fewer circuits. A 1925 Maple Ridge house in Midtown Tulsa was wired when three circuits was considered generous, and rooms were separate, so each room got its own small set of controls near its own door.

The post-2000 building wave did the opposite. Broken Arrow is the clearest example in the metro: a third of everything standing there went up after 2000, in floor plans built around two-story entries, open great rooms and long connected hallways. Add recessed cans, under-cabinet lighting, pendants over an island, a chandelier, exterior lights and a fan, and you are at a dozen controls before anyone has thought about it. Jenks, Bixby and Owasso all show the same pattern.

The result is a wall nobody in the family can read. People learn two switches and leave the rest alone, which means half the lighting in an expensive house never gets used.

What does lighting control actually replace it with?

A small keypad with four to six buttons, each of which sets an entire scene rather than a single fixture.

One button for Evening, which brings the cans to forty percent, the under-cabinet lighting to full and the pendants to a level that looks right after dark. One for Entertaining. One for Movie. One for Goodnight, which turns off everything downstairs and leaves a path light on.

Behind the wall, dimmers hold each fixture at the level set during design. The room looks the same every night without anyone adjusting anything, which is the actual product. Not the ability to control lights from your phone, which people use for about a month, but the fact that a room looks intentional every single evening with one press.

Is this a hardware problem or a design problem?

Mostly design, and this is the part people underestimate.

Choosing which fixtures belong on which scene, and at what level, is the work. Get it right and the family uses four buttons daily. Get it wrong and you have installed expensive switches that nobody understands, which is worse than the wall you started with.

Integration at Work, AV sets scene levels on site, at night, in the actual room, rather than programming them from a desk. A level that looks correct on a screen is frequently too bright in a room with dark cabinets or too dim in one with white walls and a lot of glass.

The other design rule worth knowing: about four scenes per room is the ceiling. More than that and nobody remembers them. Anything genuinely occasional belongs on the app, not on the wall.

Do I have to rewire the house?

Usually not, and this is where the Tulsa metro's construction actually helps.

Wireless dimmers and keypads retrofit into existing switch boxes in most rooms, with no new cable and no drywall repair. The wall you have gets replaced with the keypad you want, and the existing wiring stays where it is.

Where a room does need attention is when a fixture needs to move, when a circuit is genuinely overloaded, or when two fixtures that should be separately controlled are sharing a single switch leg. Those get identified during the walkthrough and priced up front rather than discovered halfway through.

Most homes in Broken Arrow and the surrounding suburbs sit on a slab, with no basement and no crawlspace, so any run that is genuinely needed goes up into the attic and drops down inside the wall. It is routine work, and it rarely requires the kind of demolition homeowners brace themselves for.

Aren't smart bulbs a cheaper way to do this?

For a single lamp, a smart bulb is the right answer and you should buy one.

For a room, it is the wrong tool, for a reason that is easy to miss until you live with it. Smart bulbs put the intelligence in the bulb, which means the wall switch has to stay switched on permanently. If anyone flips it off out of habit, the bulb loses power and becomes unreachable from the app. In a house with children, guests or a cleaner, that happens constantly.

Control at the switch and the panel keeps the wall working the way every human being expects, with the scenes layered on top. Integration at Work, AV installs it that way for exactly this reason.

What does lighting control cost in the Tulsa area?

A single room, such as a great room or a primary suite, typically runs $2,500 to $6,000.

The main living areas of an average metro home land between $8,000 and $20,000.

Whole-home lighting control on a larger new build runs $25,000 to $60,000 and up.

What moves the number is how many fixtures and circuits are involved, whether the walls are open, how many keypads you want and in what finish, and whether shades and audio end up on the same system.

When is the cheapest time to do this?

Before drywall, by a wide margin.

If you are building in Broken Arrow, Jenks, Collinsville or anywhere else in the metro, the window is open right now and it closes permanently when the walls go up. Running cable into an open wall costs a fraction of fishing it into a finished one, and nothing has to be worked around.

That is also true if you are remodeling. A kitchen down to studs is the right moment to solve the switch wall for good, because you are already paying for the access.

If the house is finished and staying finished, the wireless retrofit path is genuinely good and most of what Integration at Work, AV installs. It just costs a little more per room than doing it at the framing stage would have.

TE

Troy Erickson is the owner of Integration at Work, AV in Tulsa, Oklahoma. He has been designing and installing lighting control, motorized shades, audio, video and home networks across the Tulsa metro for over twenty years, and works on everything from 1920s Midtown homes to new construction and acreage properties. Integration at Work, AV builds on Lutron and Control4 and keeps a showroom in South Tulsa.

Good questions

Frequently asked.

A small keypad with four to six buttons, each setting an entire scene rather than one fixture. One button for Evening, one for Entertaining, one for Movie, one for Goodnight. Integration at Work, AV sets the scene levels on site so they suit the room.

Usually not. Wireless dimmers and keypads retrofit into existing switch boxes in most rooms, with no new cable and no drywall repair. Integration at Work, AV identifies any room that needs a fixture moved or a circuit split during the walkthrough and prices it up front.

For a single lamp, yes. For a room, no. Smart bulbs require the wall switch to stay on permanently, so anyone flipping it off out of habit makes the bulb unreachable. Integration at Work, AV puts control at the switch so the wall keeps working normally.

A single room runs $2,500 to $6,000. Main living areas of an average home land between $8,000 and $20,000. Whole-home lighting control on a larger new build runs $25,000 to $60,000 and up. Integration at Work, AV gives a firm, itemized number before any work begins.

Keep reading

Related guides.

Buying Guides

Will a golf simulator fit in my Tulsa home? Start with the ceiling.

Most golf simulator projects in the Tulsa area live or die on one number, and it is the ceiling. A comfortable simulator wants about 10 feet of…

Read it
Troubleshooting

Why does my WiFi die in the back bedroom?

Your WiFi dies in the back bedroom because of distance and walls, not because your router is cheap. Every wall a signal passes through costs…

Read it
Cost & Upgrade Guides

What does a smart home actually cost in the Tulsa metro?

A whole-home lighting and shading system in the Tulsa metro typically runs $25,000 to $100,000 and up. Lighting control for a single room starts in…

Read it
Free in-home design consultation

Have a question we haven't written up?

Call and ask. If it comes up twice it usually becomes a post, and if it applies to your house we will tell you straight.

Showroom

6939 S 69th East Ave
Tulsa, OK 74133

Hours

Mon – Fri · 9:00am – 5:00pm

Call NowFree Quote